Coach or therapist: who helps most to build confidence?

You know you're capable. You've got the experience, the track record, maybe even the praise. And yet you rehearse what you'll say in meetings for an hour, hold back your opinion, or turn down the opportunity because someone else would surely do it better.

Image

When you decide to do something about it, the first problem is who to ask. Coach or therapist? Both can help with confidence, and the choice isn't always obvious.


What confidence actually is

Psychologists often describe confidence as a belief in your ability to handle a particular situation, which Bandura (1977) called self-efficacy. It's built mainly through doing things and seeing that you can, and it's specific. You can feel sure of yourself running a team and entirely unsure presenting to the board. Confidence isn't a fixed trait you either have or lack; it can vary depending on the situation you're in.

It also matters because low confidence has different roots in different people. For some, it's a gap in experience or skill, or a change of role. For others, it comes from much further back, from being criticised, overlooked or told to be smaller, and the doubt follows them into every room.


When a coach is likely to fit

Coaching tends to suit you when you're functioning well, you know roughly where you want to go, and what's missing is practice, clarity and a push. It's forward-looking and practical. You might be stepping into a bigger role, preparing to speak up more, negotiating pay, or noticing that impostor feelings are holding you back at work.

In coaching, we'd look at specific situations, work out what you want to do differently, try it, and review what happened. A review of the research found that coaching has a positive effect on performance, well-being, coping, and goal-directed self-regulation (Theeboom et al., 2014), which are the building blocks of confidence at work.


When a therapist is likely to fit

Therapy might suit you when low confidence feels bigger than any one situation. That might mean it comes with persistent anxiety or low mood, a harsh inner critic you can't switch off, or a feeling of not being good enough that has been there as long as you can remember. It might also mean the doubt is tied to painful experiences such as bullying, a difficult family, or a controlling relationship.

Therapy looks backwards as well as forwards. The aim isn't to find someone to blame. It's to understand where the belief that you're not enough came from, so it can loosen its hold. A therapist can also help if confidence problems sit alongside symptoms that need proper assessment or treatment.


The grey area

Many people sit between the two, and the line isn't sharp. A senior woman who freezes in meetings might need nothing more than practical coaching and a few good rehearsals. Another, with the same symptoms, might find that the freezing comes from something old that no technique will touch. You can't always tell from the outside, and you don't have to be certain before you start.


Questions to ask yourself

Think about how long it's been going on and whether it started with a specific event. Notice whether it's mostly in one area, like work, or everywhere. Consider whether it affects your sleep, appetite, mood or relationships, and whether you're getting through the day or only just. Think about whether you'd rather work on what to do next, or on why it feels like this. If you're unsure, there's no wrong answer. A good practitioner will help you work it out.


What to ask before you book

Ask about their training, what they're qualified to do and how they'd work with someone in your position. Ask whether they'll tell you honestly if someone else would suit you better. Most coaches and therapists offer a free introductory call, so use it to see whether you feel at ease talking to them.

This article was written with AI-assisted technologies and has been reviewed and edited with human oversight, in accordance with our AI policy.

The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of Life Coach Directory. Articles are reviewed by our editorial team and offer professionals a space to share their ideas with respect and care.

Share this article with a friend
Image
Brighton, East Sussex, BN2
Image
Image
Written by Rebecca Cockayne
BA. (Oxon), MSc. WhatsApp: +447915107379
Brighton, East Sussex, BN2
Bex is a coach who loves journeys. She's done a lot and has been on many internal and external ones. She loves to help people along their path too. She specialises in coaching people on building their purpose, accessing their self confidence and...
Image

Find the right business or life coach for you

All coaches are verified professionals

All coaches are verified professionals